5 min read

Five Myths about Manual and Automatic Transmissions

John avatar by John C. Baldwin
5 min read
automatic transmission?v=1

Manual transmission vs. Automatic transmission has been a hot topic for a long time. People have been debating whether to use an automatic transmission or a manual transmission for decades. However, what are the facts and myths? Keep reading to find out more.

Most likely, the issue over automatic vs. manual transmission will never be resolved. Many experts prefer manual transmissions, but most modern car owners now prefer automatic transmissions; this is why it's hard for both groups to reach an agreement. There are many benefits to manual transmissions, but it would be unfair to say it is better than automatic transmission without comparing the two closely, to see what people think and what is true.

In recent times, some factors make some people prefer a manual gearbox over an automatic one. Regardless, we can't deny that some drivers overestimate the benefits of a manual transmission from time to time. Let's take a look at some of the most frequent manual vs automatic transmission myths:

Stick Shifts Cost Less to Purchase Compared To Automatic Transmission

To some extent, this is true. Even though the manual version of the same car model may be cheaper than the automatic transmission version in some cases, this isn't always the case. When you look at a Toyota HiAce price list, for example, you'll see that the manual models are often cheaper. This, on the other hand, doesn't apply to all cars.

Conversely, this pricing style is declining these days because automobile makers are now trying to make both automobiles cost the same. This is why if you look hard enough, you can get automatic transmission cars for the same price as manual transmission cars.  As a result, the buyer's choice will be more important than the price difference in deciding between them. Additionally, buyers won't be able to get a manual version of every car on the market, as well.

Stick Shifts Are More Fuel Efficient

When it comes to fuel economy, manual transmissions are better at offering the most out of your fuel. Despite our fondness for manual transmissions, we learned that the popular myth that they are more fuel-efficient than automatic transmissions is no longer accurate. This myth used to be true, but because of recent technological advancements, automatic transmissions now have extremely excellent fuel efficiency as well. As a result, when they are compared, the difference in fuel efficiency is quite little and trivial compared to how some people make it seem.

The Cost Of Maintaining A Manual Transmission Is Lesser Than Automatic Transmission

Manual transmissions have simple designs and are easier to repair and rebuild, but this does not mean that they will cost less to maintain. Improvements in the design and manufacturing of automatic transmissions have made it much less likely that problems will arise in the future.

Automatic transmissions, on the other hand, have been known to last longer than manual gearboxes. However, it isn't always the case with manual gearboxes that they last for the entire lifespan of the car. The transmission of a manual car would have to be changed at least twice during its lifetime. Hence, it will cost you more in the long run to use a manual transmission. As a result, buying a manual transmission isn't always the best or only choice for people looking for a cheap car.

Stick Shifts Are A Must For Cars Used In Sports

Stick shifts are standard in most sports vehicles. Even though most sports cars have a manual transmission, this doesn't mean they can't have an automatic transmission as well. There are always automatic transmission alternatives. Most current sports cars now come with both manual and automatic transmissions.

Manufacturers have recently added paddle shifts that don't need a clutch. This means that automatic transmission sports cars are now a reality. To make things even more realistic, you'll almost certainly come across a sports car with an automatic transmission.

Stick Shifts are More Ideal for Heavy-Duty Works

Many people think that a manual transmission is the best choice for heavy-duty work.  It's worth noting that the clutch on a manual car might get worn down over time. On the other hand, an automatic transmission is more reliable because it doesn't have a clutch that might need to be changed at some point. Also, a towing package is available on many heavy-duty cars with automatic transmission.

Manual transmission cars still have some long-term advantages, like the ability to be rescued by another car nearby when it gets stuck, as well as a few other advantages. However, an automatic transmission is now standard on most new cars, and it is the consumer's favorite way to get around. As new technologies come out every day, automatic transmissions are also getting better. This is something to think about when you buy a new car. Since we've helped you debunk some of the most common myths and facts surrounding manual versus automatic transmission discussions, we hope you'll make the best decision possible the next time you decide to buy a car. Make sure you are buying a good vehicle and use a service like EpicVIN before making a final decision.

Buying a Used car?
Check it by Epicvin
  • Safe checkout guaranteed
  • Niada logo
  • Blockchain confirmed data
More Articles
View All

Save Thousands of Dollars

Learn everything there is to know about your next car.

Where to find the VIN? No VIN?
Get EpicVIN reports

  • Safe checkout guaranteed
  • Niada logo
  • Blockchain confirmed data