Purchasing a used car should certainly be accompanied by conducting a vehicle's history report. Such reports uncover a car's past. Feel free to find out the accident history and ownership details. However, a question arises: With multiple providers offering these services, which one delivers the most comprehensive report? Let's examine how two vehicle history report providers (BeenVerified and Carfax) stack up.
Definition of a Vehicle History Report
A vehicle history report includes data about a certain vehicle. Detailed information is obtained through a vehicle identification number (VIN). Alternatively, check a license plate number. These history reports usually reveal data about reported accidents and title information. Nevertheless, they also uncover service history, ownership history, and odometer readings. A vehicle history report includes facts about former owners and sale history.
In general, obtaining a used car's history through these reports helps avoid purchasing vehicles with hidden damage/history issues.
When Do You Need to Get a Vehicle History Report?
Obtaining a vehicle history report is an essential procedure before purchasing any used vehicle. These reports represent an additional cost in your car purchase journey. Nevertheless, they can save you thousands in the future. You should always get a vehicle's history report when:
- Purchasing a used car from a private seller or a dealership.
- The car's price seems suspiciously low (below the market value).
- You notice inconsistencies in information about the car's past.
- No warranties are provided for a used car.
- A car with a loan from a previous owner.
- Verifying whether the given vehicle has manufacturer recalls.
- Reviewing the accuracy of the vehicle's mileage.
- Checking for major accidents or airbags deployment in an accident.
BeenVerified vs Carfax: A Side-by-Side Breakdown
How BeenVerified and Carfax Differ in Data Sources
When comparing these services, a significant difference lies in their data collection methods. Carfax has established itself as a specialist in automotive industry reporting, while BeenVerified functions primarily as an online background check service that offers vehicle reports. This affects the depth of detailed report information each provides.
| Feature | BeenVerified | Carfax |
| Primary Function | General background check company | Automotive-specific vehicle history specialist |
| Data Sources | Public records, government databases | 100,000+ sources, including DMVs, service shops, insurance companies |
| Accident Data | Basic accident reports | Detailed accident history, including severity and damage occurred |
| Maintenance Information | Limited service history | Comprehensive maintenance records, including oil changes |
| Recall Information | Basic manufacturer recalls | Detailed open recalls with specific information related to the vehicle |
| Criminal Records Check | Includes criminal background on previous owners | Focuses solely on the vehicle's history |
| Employment History | Can provide previous owners' employment information | Does not include personal data about ownership history/ownership costs |
Price Comparison
BeenVerified and Carfax represent different pricing information approaches. BeenVerified operates on a subscription model for multiple reports, while Carfax typically charges per vehicle report with some bundles. Both are considered paid services with different value propositions.
BeenVerified Pricing:
- Monthly subscription: $36.89/month for access to BeenVerified's features.
- 3-month subscription: $23.98/month ($71.94 total).
- No option for a single report.
- Access to various sources beyond vehicle data.
Carfax Pricing:
- One report: $44.99.
- Four-report package: $109.99 ($27.50 per report).
- Unlimited reports from a single dealer: Often provided free by dealerships.
- Free Carfax report sample available.
- Some insurance companies may provide free Carfax report access.
- Considered a premium paid service with comprehensive data.
Report Readability and Ease of Use
The presentation of information impacts how easily consumers can interpret details about a vehicle's past. Both companies have different approaches to report design and user experience. Having up-to-date reports with clear visuals helps buyers make informed decisions.
| Feature | BeenVerified | Carfax |
| Report Format | Basic text-heavy design | Color-coded sections with icons and visual indicators |
| Mobile Experience | App available but less optimized | Mobile-friendly design, easily searchable from any device |
| Red Flag Indicators | Basic issue highlighting | Clear visual alerts for serious problems |
| VIN Decoder Tool | Basic VIN decoder capabilities | Advanced VIN decoder with detailed specifications |
| Timeline View | Limited chronological presentation | Clear timeline showing complete history |
| Summary Section | Basic overview | "Quick Check" summary highlighting key issues |
| Data Visualization | Minimal visual elements | Visual odometer charts and condition indicators |
| Export Options | Limited sharing | Easy PDF exports and sharing options |
Customer Reviews of BeenVerified and Carfax
Carfax Reviews
Carfax has established itself as the industry standard, with millions of users relying on its services. Online reviews highlight both the strengths and limitations of their reporting. Many users note that Carfax reports provide accurate and substantial insights into a vehicle's condition.
Pros:
- Carfax reports provide crucial insights on accidents, ownership history, and odometer readings.
- The service has helped buyers avoid purchasing vehicles with hidden mileage discrepancies.
- Many users find Carfax worth the cost.
- Carfax reports can be used to negotiate better deals.
- Many buyers trust Carfax for its credibility and recognition in the automotive industry.
Cons:
- Some reports contain errors, such as incorrect accident history or inaccurate ownership details.
- Customers who encounter inaccuracies in their reports often find it challenging to get corrections.
- A Carfax report does not always reveal the source of reported damage.
- Some customers have experienced billing issues, including being charged for extra months.
- Carfax subscriptions can be expensive compared to alternatives.
BeenVerified Reviews
As a broader background check service, BeenVerified offers vehicle history as one of many search types. Users searching for the perfect car often use this service for initial screening.
Pros:
- BeenVerified provides detailed car history reports, including past services and accidents.
- The reports are well-organized and easy to understand.
- It is useful for checking multiple vehicles quickly.
- The information provided is comprehensive and includes valuable insights.
- Users appreciate the ability to look up VIN numbers before buying a car.
Cons:
- Some users report inaccurate or missing information.
- Customers have complained about unexpected subscription charges.
- The platform does not always provide complete vehicle history, as some reports lack insurance records.
- Some users feel that the quality of the reports is not as high as competitors.
- There are complaints about customer service, with difficulties reaching a representative.
How to Get Vehicle History Information for Free
Not everyone can afford paid vehicle history reports. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration offers a free VIN lookup tool for recall information. Some dealerships offer free Carfax report access. Furthermore, don’t hesitate to request service records from previous owners. You can also check with local DMVs for title data and inspect the vehicle carefully for signs of repairs.
EpicVIN VIN Check as a Carfax Free Alternative
EpicVIN has emerged as a notable Carfax alternative offering NMVTIS-certified vehicle history reports at a lower price point. Their reports include essential data such as title information, odometer reading, and accident history.
EpicVIN provides more affordable reports. The service draws from similar government and insurance company databases as higher-priced competitors. For buyers primarily concerned with title history problems and accident history, EpicVIN represents a valuable option.
Vehicle Reports' Most Ignored Warning Signs
Even with comprehensive report options, many buyers overlook critical red flags. Understanding what these warning signs mean is crucial for making informed decisions about a used vehicle purchase.
Key warning signs frequently overlooked include:
- Gaps in the vehicle's history where ownership or mileage information is missing.
- Multiple ownership changes in short periods.
- Salvage title or previous total loss declarations that impact market value.
- Inconsistent odometer readings that may indicate tampering.
- History of flood or fire damage.
- Recurring mechanical problems of the same type.
- Airbags deployment in an accident without proper replacement documentation.
- Title brands like "lemon law buyback."
- Accident history followed by minimal repair costs.
How Often Do Car History Reports Get Things Wrong?
No vehicle history report is perfect. As per the latest research, approximately 20% of reports may contain inaccurate facts. These gaps emerge when accidents go unreported to insurance companies. Sometimes, repairs are private. In some cases, data entry errors happen.
In general, vehicle history reports provide valuable information. However, they shouldn’t be considered the only tool in the buyer's due diligence process.
Common Gaps in Vehicle History Reports
Even comprehensive vehicle history reports have inherent limitations. Understanding these common gaps helps buyers know when additional investigation is necessary. These limitations exist across all vehicle history report providers, including premium services.
The most significant information gaps in most reports include:
- Minor accidents paid out-of-pocket without insurance claims.
- Mechanical repairs performed by independent shops that don't report to databases.
- Damage that didn't trigger an insurance claim or police report.
- DIY repairs and modifications by previous owners.
- Issues in states with less stringent reporting requirements.
- Very recent accidents or title changes not yet in databases.
- Details about repair quality following reported accidents.
- Problems with vehicles that spent time in other countries.
- Cosmetic damage that doesn't affect operation or safety.
- Environmental exposure damage affecting longevity.
Further reading
Summary
When choosing between BeenVerified and Carfax, pay attention to the distinct advantages these services offer. Carfax opens more detailed vehicle-specific information with comprehensive accident history and maintenance documentation. The service is ideal for evaluating a single vehicle.
BeenVerified offers more affordable access to multiple reports with broader background information. For the most complete picture, consider using these services as complementary tools, potentially using BeenVerified to screen multiple vehicles before requesting a Carfax review on your final selection. Both providers offer valuable insights that help potential buyers make informed decisions about salvage records and overall vehicle condition.
With EpicVIN, consumers can access essential vehicle details through comprehensive reports, including a free VIN lookup option to preview critical data upfront.
Frequently Asked Questions
Verifying your VIN online through reputable vehicle history report providers is safe. Your VIN number is already visible on your dashboard and in the documents. Thus, there are no risks when using the code to access public records about your vehicle. Just use established services to protect your information.
While uncommon, some sellers attempt to falsify vehicle history reports. To protect yourself:
- Verify that the VIN number on the report matches the actual vehicle.
- Request to run the report yourself through the provider's website.
- Look for inconsistencies in formatting or fonts that may indicate tampering.
- Cross-reference with service records or a mechanic's inspection.
- Watch out if the seller refuses to let you conduct your report.
Vehicle history reports don't disclose contact information for previous owners. This is due to privacy regulations. While they show the number of past owners and sometimes locations, personal details like phone numbers are removed. For legitimate reconnection needs, DMV channels with proper documentation are more appropriate.
Yes. Using a VIN decoder (alternatively, a license plate lookup check) before selling is recommended. This lets you address buyer concerns, accurately represent your used car's history, and set an appropriate asking price. It also helps identify any report inaccuracies that you can explain to prospective buyers.
No states prohibit vehicle history checks, but information availability varies by location:
- California has stricter privacy laws limiting some public record information.
- Some states require additional documentation to access certain vehicle records.
- Privacy laws regarding previous owner information vary by state.
- All states follow the federal Driver's Privacy Protection Act regulations.
