Used Mazda Mx-5 for Sale in St James, NY

Showing 24 of 44 listings

No matches found.

Save your search and we will notify you when we have cars that match your search criteria.

We expanded your search distance and we're unable to find cars that match.

Try adjusting your filters, or start a new search.

$29,998
$29,998 above
$885/mo est. ?
23,979 km

CarMax Smithtown

11787, Smithtown NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
3 km

Garden City Mazda

4.5 Google 1514 reviews

11550, Hempstead NY

Check Details
$38,410
$38,410 above
$1,130/mo est. ?
0 km 2.0L

Mazda 112

11763, Medford NY

Check Details
$37,625
$37,625 above
$1,107/mo est. ?
0 km

Riverhead Mazda

11901, Riverhead NY

Check Details
$33,925
$33,925 above
$1,000/mo est. ?
4,466 km

11780, Saint James NY

Check Details
$41,835
$41,835 above
$1,231/mo est. ?
0 km

Wantagh Mazda

11793, Wantagh NY

Check Details
$40,805
$40,805 above
$1,201/mo est. ?
0 km

Wantagh Mazda

11793, Wantagh NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
18 km

Garden City Mazda

4.5 Google 1514 reviews

11550, Hempstead NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
3 km

Garden City Mazda

4.5 Google 1514 reviews

11550, Hempstead NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
3 km

Garden City Mazda

4.5 Google 1514 reviews

11550, Hempstead NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
26 km

Garden City Mazda

4.5 Google 1514 reviews

11550, Hempstead NY

Check Details
$40,770
$40,770 above
$1,200/mo est. ?
0 km 2.0L

Mazda of Milford

4.5 Google 399 reviews

06460, Milford CT

Check Details
$37,995
$37,995 above
$1,120/mo est. ?
6,593 km

Smith Haven Mazda

11780, Saint James NY

Check Details
$33,495
$33,495 above
$988/mo est. ?
39,294 km

11780, St James NY

Check Details
$38,630
$38,630 above
$1,137/mo est. ?
0 km 2.0L

Bright Bay Mazda

4.7 Google 538 reviews

11706, Bay Shore NY

Check Details
$24,998
$24,998 above
$737/mo est. ?
96,417 km

CarMax Smithtown

11787, Smithtown NY

Check Details
$36,075
$36,075 above
$1,062/mo est. ?
0 km

Wantagh Mazda

11793, Wantagh NY

Check Details
$37,920
$37,920 above
$1,116/mo est. ?
0 km

Wantagh Mazda

11793, Wantagh NY

Check Details
$20,224
$20,224 above
$596/mo est. ?
97,632 km

Napoli Auto Xpress

06460, Milford CT

Check Details
$38,570
$38,570 above
$1,135/mo est. ?
0 km 2.0L

Mazda 112

11763, Medford NY

Check Details
$24,998
$24,998 above
$737/mo est. ?
19,594 km

CarMax East Meadow - Now Open

11554, East Meadow NY

Check Details
$22,999
$22,999 above
$678/mo est. ?
51,500 km

Land Rover Huntington

4.3 Google 347 reviews

11743, Huntington NY

Check Details
$34,688
$34,688 above
$1,023/mo est. ?
24,695 km

Garden City Mazda

4.5 Google 1514 reviews

11550, Hempstead NY

Check Details
$33,495
$33,495 above
$988/mo est. ?
7,738 km

11780, St James NY

Check Details

Frequently Asked Questions

Our marketplace currently lists 44 used cars in St James, NY from dealers and private sellers. Prices range from $31,692 to $33,360.

Top brands by active listings in St James, NY are Mazda. The mix often reflects local buying preferences.

The average listed price in St James, NY is $32,804. Browse by budget: under $10,000, under $20,000, or under $30,000.

No — you can buy from a seller in St James, NY regardless of your state of residence. You'll need to register and title the vehicle in your home state within the required window (usually 30 days). Local dealers typically handle paperwork for out-of-state buyers.

Yes — popular nearby options include cities across the state. You can also browse all used cars in New York.