Used Subaru Legacy for Sale in West Islip, NY

Showing 24 of 54 listings

No matches found.

Save your search and we will notify you when we have cars that match your search criteria.

We expanded your search distance and we're unable to find cars that match.

Try adjusting your filters, or start a new search.

$31,003
$31,003 above
$914/mo est. ?
27,748 km 2.5L

Infiniti of Manhasset

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11563, Lynbrook NY

Check Details
$22,898
$22,898 above
$675/mo est. ?
41,297 km 2.5L

Subaru Stamford

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

06902, Stamford CT

Check Details
$28,849
$28,849 above
$851/mo est. ?
3,013 km 2.5L

Subaru Stamford

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

06902, Stamford CT

Check Details
$27,142
$27,142 above
$800/mo est. ?
26,617 km

Subaru Stamford

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

06902, Stamford CT

Check Details
$28,548
$28,548 above
$842/mo est. ?
3,708 km 2.5L

Subaru Stamford

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

06902, Stamford CT

Check Details
$26,670
$26,670 above
$786/mo est. ?
24,217 km 2.5L

Sunrise Toyota North

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11953, Middle Island NY

Check Details
$9,500
$9,500 above
$280/mo est. ?
104,929 km

Cargenic Automotive

11757, Lindenhurst NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
16,927 km 2.5L

SCA Auctions

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

5.0
Star icon
1 review
4.1 Google 55 reviews

11763, MEDFORD NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
209,327 km 2.5L

SCA Auctions

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

5.0
Star icon
1 review
4.1 Google 55 reviews

11763, MEDFORD NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
24,534 km

Empire Subaru

4.6 Google 904 reviews

11743, Huntington NY

Check Details
$15,998
$15,998 above
$472/mo est. ?
98,532 km

CarMax Smithtown

11787, Smithtown NY

Check Details
$9,500
$9,500 above
$280/mo est. ?
151,210 km 2.5L

11727, Coram NY

Check Details
$32,690
$32,690 above
$964/mo est. ?
5,300 km

Subaru Stamford

06902, Stamford CT

Check Details
$1,250
$1,250 above
$37/mo est. ?
313,865 km 2.5L

A Better Bid Online Car Auctions

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

5.0
Star icon
1 review
3.7 Google 199 reviews

11719, BROOKHAVEN NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
48,911 km

L.I. Auto Gallery

11751, Islip NY

Check Details
$29,895
$29,895 above
$882/mo est. ?
44,950 km

Toyota of Stamford

06902, Stamford CT

Check Details
Get a price quote
152,435 km

DSA Motor Sports Corp

11725, Commack NY

Check Details
$10,995
$10,995 above
$324/mo est. ?
153,748 km

Sylhet Motors Inc.

4.6 Google 344 reviews

11432, Jamaica NY

Check Details
$9,495
$9,495 above
$280/mo est. ?
152,652 km

Sylhet Motors Inc.

4.6 Google 344 reviews

11432, Jamaica NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
183,370 km 3.6L

SCA Auctions

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

5.0
Star icon
1 review
4.1 Google 55 reviews

11763, MEDFORD NY

Check Details
Get a price quote
171,113 km 2.5L

SCA Auctions

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

5.0
Star icon
1 review
4.1 Google 55 reviews

11763, MEDFORD NY

Check Details
$12,445
$12,445 above
$367/mo est. ?
141,894 km

Road Masters II Inc.

11379, Middle Village NY

Check Details
$36,461
$36,461 above
$1,075/mo est. ?
3 km

East Hills Subaru of Sayville

11782, Sayville NY

Check Details
$28,498
$28,498 above
$840/mo est. ?
15,142 km

South Shore Subaru

4.8 Google 583 reviews

11757, Lindenhurst NY

Check Details

Frequently Asked Questions

Our marketplace currently lists 54 used cars in West Islip, NY from dealers and private sellers. Prices range from $8,757 to $8,757.

Top brands by active listings in West Islip, NY are Subaru. The mix often reflects local buying preferences.

The average listed price in West Islip, NY is $8,757. Browse by budget: under $10,000, under $20,000, or under $30,000.

No — you can buy from a seller in West Islip, NY regardless of your state of residence. You'll need to register and title the vehicle in your home state within the required window (usually 30 days). Local dealers typically handle paperwork for out-of-state buyers.

Yes — popular nearby options include cities across the state. You can also browse all used cars in New York.