Used Subaru Legacy for Sale in Middleton, WI

Showing 24 of 35 listings

No matches found.

Save your search and we will notify you when we have cars that match your search criteria.

We expanded your search distance and we're unable to find cars that match.

Try adjusting your filters, or start a new search.

$20,890
$20,890 above
$616/mo est. ?
146,724 km 2.5L

Kunes Mitsubishi of Madison

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

53713, Madison WI

Check Details
$11,995
$11,995 above
$354/mo est. ?
178,700 km

Lot 51 Auto Sales

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

53716, Madison WI

Check Details
$31,857
$31,857 above
$939/mo est. ?
12,677 km

Don Miller Subaru West

4.7 Google 1281 reviews

53719, Madison WI

Check Details
$29,997
$29,997 above
$885/mo est. ?
9,905 km

Don Miller Subaru

53719, Madison WI

Check Details
Get a price quote
218,613 km 2.5L

SCA Auctions

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

5.0
Star icon
1 review
4.1 Google 55 reviews

53901, PORTAGE WI

Check Details
Get a price quote
219,316 km

Zimbrick at Fish Hatchery Road

53713, Madison WI

Check Details
$21,989
$21,989 above
$648/mo est. ?
53,198 km

53704, Madison WI

Check Details
$16,995
$16,995 above
$501/mo est. ?
165,868 km 2.5L

Goben Cars West

4.7 Google 851 reviews

53562, Middleton WI

Check Details
$29,750
$29,750 above
$877/mo est. ?
15,411 km

Schoepp Motors West

53562, Middleton WI

Check Details
$26,993
$26,993 above
$796/mo est. ?
22,585 km

Don Miller Subaru East

53718, Madison WI

Check Details
$7,900
$7,900 above
$233/mo est. ?
281,844 km 2.5L

Golden Cars

53704, Madison WI

Check Details
$30,657
$30,657 above
$902/mo est. ?
0 km

Don Miller East

4.2
Star icon
5 reviews

53718, Madison WI

Check Details
$25,286
$25,286 above
$746/mo est. ?
42,160 km

Car Smart of Memphis

53704, Madison WI

Check Details
$21,844
$21,844 above
$644/mo est. ?
106,065 km

Wilde East Towne Honda

4.5 Google 1080 reviews

53718, Madison WI

Check Details
$20,994
$20,994 above
$619/mo est. ?
60,321 km

Russ Darrow Kia Madison

53719, Madison WI

Check Details
$14,997
$14,997 above
$442/mo est. ?
244,209 km

Schoepp Motors - Northeast

53704, Madison WI

Check Details
$14,954
$14,954 above
$441/mo est. ?
119,228 km

Driveway

53718, Madison WI

Check Details
$18,995
$18,995 above
$560/mo est. ?
166,536 km

Schoepp Motors West

53562, Middleton WI

Check Details
$19,995
$19,995 above
$590/mo est. ?
128,139 km

Goben Cars West

4.7 Google 851 reviews

53562, Middleton WI

Check Details
$27,999
$27,999 above
$826/mo est. ?
20,685 km

Schoepp Motors - Northeast

53704, Madison WI

Check Details
$5,900
$5,900 above
$174/mo est. ?
230,844 km 3.6L

Penguin Auto

53719, Madison WI

Check Details
$27,242
$27,242 above
$803/mo est. ?
43,486 km 2.5L

Wilde East Towne Honda

4.5 Google 1080 reviews

53718, Madison WI

Check Details
$24,374
$24,374 above
$719/mo est. ?
53,375 km

Don Miller Subaru

53719, Madison WI

Check Details
$28,374
$28,374 above
$837/mo est. ?
37,662 km

Don Miller Subaru

53719, Madison WI

Check Details

Frequently Asked Questions

Our marketplace currently lists 35 used cars in Middleton, WI from dealers and private sellers. Prices range from $16,680 to $29,607.

Top brands by active listings in Middleton, WI are Subaru. The mix often reflects local buying preferences.

The average listed price in Middleton, WI is $21,163. Browse by budget: under $10,000, under $20,000, or under $30,000.

No — you can buy from a seller in Middleton, WI regardless of your state of residence. You'll need to register and title the vehicle in your home state within the required window (usually 30 days). Local dealers typically handle paperwork for out-of-state buyers.

Yes — popular nearby options include cities across the state. You can also browse all used cars in Wisconsin.