Used Cars for Sale in Bay Shore, NY Under $75,000

No matches found.

Save your search and we will notify you when we have cars that match your search criteria.

We expanded your search distance and we're unable to find cars that match.

Try adjusting your filters, or start a new search.

$25,349
$25,349 above
$748/mo est. ?
33,168 km

Advantage Hyundai

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.1 Google 1043 reviews

11801, Hicksville NY

Check Details
$14,495
$14,495 above
$427/mo est. ?
71,413 km

112 Auto Sales

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11772, Patchogue NY

Check Details
$16,495
$16,495 above
$486/mo est. ?
112,842 km

112 Auto Sales

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11772, Patchogue NY

Check Details

To save your search and get updates on new inventory and price drops, sign up for a profile

Sign up
$13,995
$13,995 above
$413/mo est. ?
157,049 km

112 Auto Sales

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11772, Patchogue NY

Check Details
$11,900
$11,900 above
$351/mo est. ?
121,000 km

112 Auto Sales

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11772, Patchogue NY

Check Details
$16,495
$16,495 above
$486/mo est. ?
173,159 km

112 Auto Sales

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11772, Patchogue NY

Check Details
$21,395
$21,395 above
$631/mo est. ?
28,162 km

Empire Ford/Lincoln

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.3 Google 717 reviews

11743, Huntington NY

Check Details
$37,907
$37,907 above
$1,118/mo est. ?
14,339 km

Habberstad BMW of Bay Shore

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11706, Bay Shore NY

Check Details
$42,401
$42,401 above
$1,250/mo est. ?
60,527 km

Habberstad BMW of Bay Shore

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11706, Bay Shore NY

Check Details

Save a search, and we'll alert you when there are new listings that match exactly what you're looking for.

$32,295
$32,295 above
$952/mo est. ?
80,942 km

Import Masters

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11021, Great Neck NY

Check Details
$33,619
$33,619 above
$991/mo est. ?
44,432 km

Habberstad BMW of Bay Shore

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11706, Bay Shore NY

Check Details
$44,349
$44,349 above
$1,308/mo est. ?
50,744 km

Habberstad BMW of Bay Shore

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11706, Bay Shore NY

Check Details
$16,904
$16,904 above
$498/mo est. ?
100,265 km

Habberstad BMW

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.7 Google 2489 reviews

11746, Huntington Station NY

Check Details
$43,500
$43,500 above
$1,283/mo est. ?
14,938 km

Lincoln of Smithtown

11780, St James NY

Check Details
$14,327
$14,327 above
$422/mo est. ?
91,501 km

Advantage Hyundai

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.1 Google 1043 reviews

11801, Hicksville NY

Check Details
$23,499
$23,499 above
$693/mo est. ?
17,862 km

Star Hyundai

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.1 Google 479 reviews

11361, Bayside NY

Check Details
$28,775
$28,775 above
$849/mo est. ?
69,594 km

Lincoln of Smithtown

11780, St James NY

Check Details
$34,995
$34,995 above
$1,032/mo est. ?
100,066 km

Lincoln of Smithtown

11780, St James NY

Check Details
$29,195
$29,195 above
$861/mo est. ?
49,119 km 2.3L

Lincoln of Smithtown

11780, St James NY

Check Details
$28,555
$28,555 above
$842/mo est. ?
50,023 km 2.3L

Lincoln of Smithtown

11780, St James NY

Check Details
$28,556
$28,556 above
$842/mo est. ?
22,978 km

Advantage Hyundai

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

4.1 Google 1043 reviews

11801, Hicksville NY

Check Details
$32,995
$32,995 above
$973/mo est. ?
55,120 km

Import Masters

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11021, Great Neck NY

Check Details
$22,695
$22,695 above
$669/mo est. ?
62,084 km

Import Masters

Authorized EpicVIN dealer

11021, Great Neck NY

Check Details
$66,947
$66,947 above
$1,974/mo est. ?
3,594 km

Hassett Automotive of Wantagh

11793, Wantagh NY

Check Details